Japan Could Have Become the World’s Economic Superpower

The story of Japan’s economic rise and prolonged stagnation offers a powerful lesson for developing economies such as Nigeria and Ghana: building a productive economy is difficult, but sustaining it requires even greater discipline.

In the 1980s, Japan looked almost unstoppable.

Its automobile manufacturers were challenging American giants. Its electronics companies were dominating international markets. Its semiconductor industry was becoming a formidable global competitor, while Japanese banks and corporations were accumulating enormous financial power.

Japan was not simply participating in the global economy. It was reshaping it.

By 1985, Japan had become the world’s second-largest economy, behind the United States. Japanese companies were purchasing prominent American properties, and there was growing concern in the United States about Japan’s economic dominance.

The purchase of Rockefeller Center by Mitsubishi Estate in 1989 became one of the most visible symbols of Japan’s economic ambitions.

At the time, many believed Japan’s economic rise was unstoppable.

But something went wrong.

Today, Japan remains one of the world’s largest and most technologically advanced economies, but its prolonged economic stagnation has become one of the most studied economic stories in modern history.

So what happened?

The agreement that changed the economic landscape

On 22 September 1985, representatives of five major industrial economies met at the Plaza Hotel in New York and signed what became known as the Plaza Accord.

The United States, Japan, West Germany, France and the United Kingdom agreed to coordinate efforts to reduce the value of the US dollar against other major currencies.

The agreement was largely driven by American concerns about the strength of the dollar and the growing US trade deficit.

Japan’s participation had significant consequences.

The Japanese yen appreciated substantially against the US dollar, making Japanese exports more expensive for international buyers.

For a country whose economic success was heavily dependent on manufacturing and exports, this created a serious challenge.

Japanese manufacturers had to reconsider their international competitiveness. Some began moving production facilities overseas to reduce costs.

However, the Plaza Accord did not destroy Japan’s economy overnight. Japan continued to experience economic growth after the agreement.

The bigger problem emerged from the economic and financial decisions that followed.

When cheap money created an expensive problem

To support economic growth and offset the impact of the stronger yen, Japan’s central bank reduced interest rates.

Borrowing became cheaper, encouraging businesses and individuals to invest.

But instead of directing all that money towards productive activities, enormous amounts flowed into property and financial markets.

Japan experienced an extraordinary asset-price boom.

Property prices soared. Stock market valuations became increasingly detached from economic fundamentals. Banks expanded lending, and businesses accumulated assets.

The Nikkei stock market reached an extraordinary peak of 38,915 points in December 1989.

For many investors, the Japanese economic miracle appeared unstoppable.

Then the bubble burst.

Stock prices collapsed, property values fell, businesses struggled with enormous debts, and financial institutions found themselves exposed to bad loans.

The country entered a prolonged period of economic stagnation.

The rise of zombie companies

One of the most important lessons from Japan’s experience concerns what happened after the financial bubble collapsed.

Normally, when a business becomes unprofitable and cannot recover, it should restructure, sell its assets or close down.

This allows capital, workers and other resources to move towards more productive businesses.

Japan struggled to make this adjustment.

Many banks were reluctant to recognise the full extent of their bad loans. Rather than forcing some struggling companies to restructure or close, financial institutions continued supporting businesses that were no longer economically viable.

These companies became known as zombie companies.

They continued operating, but their productivity and profitability were often weak.

The consequences were significant.

Money that could have financed new businesses, technological innovation and more productive companies remained tied up in struggling enterprises.

This slowed the process of economic renewal.

Japan’s experience demonstrated that protecting businesses indefinitely does not necessarily protect an economy. Sometimes it prevents an economy from becoming stronger.

Japan did not stop manufacturing

There is an important misconception about Japan’s economic decline: the suggestion that the country simply stopped producing and became an economy based entirely on lending money.

That is not accurate.

Japan remains a major manufacturing power.

Companies such as Toyota, Honda, Sony and numerous Japanese industrial technology manufacturers continue to compete internationally.

Japan is also particularly strong in robotics, precision engineering, advanced materials, industrial machinery and semiconductor manufacturing equipment.

What changed was the structure of its economy.

Japanese companies increasingly expanded their manufacturing operations overseas. At the same time, Japan became one of the world’s largest international creditor nations.

Its companies and financial institutions invested substantial amounts in foreign assets.

This generated overseas income, but it also reflected a period in which domestic investment and economic dynamism were weaker than they could have been.

Japan had become very good at investing internationally, but struggled to generate sufficient domestic economic momentum.

Why Japan struggled for so long

The collapse of the asset bubble was only the beginning.

Japan subsequently faced several interconnected challenges.

1. An ageing population

Japan’s population has been ageing rapidly, with fewer young people entering the workforce. This has created pressure on productivity, public finances and domestic consumption.

2. Deflation

For years, Japan struggled with falling or stagnant prices. When consumers and businesses expect prices to fall, they may delay spending and investment, weakening economic activity.

3. Weak domestic investment

Many businesses became cautious about expanding, hiring and investing in new opportunities.

4. Banking problems

The slow recognition of bad loans weakened financial institutions and delayed the allocation of capital towards more productive businesses.

5. Structural challenges

Japan faced difficulties adapting parts of its economy to changing global competition, technology and productivity requirements.

The result was what became popularly known as Japan’s Lost Decades.

Could Japan have become the world’s largest economy?

This is an interesting question.

Japan had many of the ingredients required to become an even greater economic power: world-class manufacturing, advanced technology, a highly educated workforce, strong corporations and considerable financial resources.

Could it have overtaken the United States?

Possibly, but that remains speculation.

Economic leadership is not determined by manufacturing alone. Population, productivity, innovation, domestic consumption, financial stability and international influence all matter.

Japan’s experience shows that even an extraordinarily successful economy can lose momentum when financial excesses, structural weaknesses and delayed reforms combine.

Today, Japan remains a major economic power, despite having been overtaken by Germany in nominal GDP in 2023 and falling to fourth place in 2024.

What should Nigeria and Ghana learn from Japan?

Perhaps the most important reason to study Japan is not simply to understand what went wrong, but to recognise the lessons for developing economies.

Nigeria and Ghana have enormous economic potential.

Nigeria has a large domestic market, significant natural resources and an entrepreneurial population. Ghana has important natural resources, a growing services sector and opportunities in manufacturing and agro-processing.

Yet both countries continue to face challenges around industrialisation, infrastructure, currency stability, access to affordable financing and dependence on imported products.

Japan’s experience offers several lessons.

First, manufacturing must be taken seriously.

A country cannot build a resilient economy simply by exporting raw materials and importing finished products.

Developing local manufacturing creates employment, strengthens technical expertise, encourages innovation and retains more economic value domestically.

Second, access to finance must translate into productive investment.

Cheap loans are not automatically good for an economy. What matters is whether the money finances businesses, infrastructure, technology and activities that increase productivity.

Third, governments must be careful about protecting failing businesses.

There is a difference between supporting a viable business during a temporary crisis and continually financing an enterprise that has no realistic path to recovery.

Fourth, economic policy must be consistent.

Businesses need predictable policies, stable institutions and a regulatory environment that allows long-term planning.

Finally, investment in people and technology is essential.

Factories alone do not create industrial competitiveness. Skilled workers, engineers, researchers, reliable infrastructure and technological innovation are equally important.

The bigger lesson: Building an economy is not enough; sustaining it matters

Japan’s story is not simply a story of a country that made one mistake in 1985.

It is a story of economic success, financial excess, policy miscalculations, delayed reforms and structural challenges.

The Plaza Accord contributed to the conditions that followed, but it was not solely responsible for Japan’s prolonged stagnation.

The more important lesson is that economic strength must be continuously renewed.

A country can have the best factories, the most advanced technology and some of the world’s strongest corporations, yet still struggle if its financial system misallocates resources and its economic policies fail to adapt.

For Nigeria and Ghana, the message should be clear.

Natural resources are not enough. A large population is not enough. Foreign investment is not enough. Even economic growth figures are not enough.

What matters is the ability to build productive industries, develop human capital, encourage innovation and create an economy that can withstand changing global conditions.

Japan’s experience should remind African policymakers that the goal should not merely be to become wealthy.

The goal should be to build an economy capable of remaining productive, competitive and resilient for generations.

error: Content is protected !!